GMP, lump sum and cost-plus contracts differ on one question: who pays when the job costs more than planned, and who keeps the money when it costs less. Under lump sum the contractor carries both. Under cost-plus the owner carries both. A GMP splits them at a cap. The owner carries cost below it, the contractor carries cost above it, and savings are usually shared. Picking a contract pricing model is a risk decision before it is a price decision. As the estimator, your job in preconstruction is to match the pricing model to how well the scope is actually defined, then price it honestly so the owner signs off knowing what they hold and what you hold. Below is a side-by-side table, then cost-plus vs GMP, who carries what, when each fits, and one $5M job priced three ways.
GMP vs Lump Sum vs Cost-Plus at a Glance
The short version: lump sum fixes the price, cost-plus fixes the fee, and GMP fixes the ceiling.
| Lump sum | Cost-plus | GMP | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What the owner pays | One fixed price for the defined scope | Actual cost of the work plus a fee, with no ceiling | Actual cost of the work plus a fee, up to a ceiling |
| Who pays an overrun | Contractor | Owner | Owner below the cap, contractor above it |
| Who keeps a saving | Contractor | Owner, because it only pays actual cost | Split under the savings clause, or all to the owner |
| Books | Closed, the owner sees the price only | Open, the owner audits cost | Open, the owner audits cost |
| Design needed to sign | Complete, or close to it | The least of the three | Enough to price a cap, often before documents are complete |
| Contingency | Inside the price, the contractor keeps what is unused | Not needed inside the price, because the owner pays actual cost | The contractor's contingency sits inside the cap |
| Contractor's main risk | Scope missed in the takeoff | Disputes over what counts as cost or fee | A cap set too early, or underpriced allowances |
| Owner's main risk | Paying for contingency that is never used | No ceiling on total cost | Allowances and assumptions that let the cap rise |
| AIA owner-contractor form | A101-2017 (stipulated sum) | A103-2017 (cost plus a fee, without a GMP) | A102-2017, or A133-2019 when a construction manager builds |
Unit price, the fourth model, pays a fixed rate per unit installed and usually sits as line items inside a lump sum or GMP contract. It is covered below.
GMP in Brief
GMP stands for guaranteed maximum price: the contractor bills actual cost plus a fee up to a cap, carries any overrun above it, and usually shares any underrun through a savings clause. For the full definition, what builds the cap, the GMP amendment and the AIA forms it runs on, see the guaranteed maximum price glossary entry.
What Is a Cost-Plus Contract, and How Is It Different From a GMP?
A cost-plus contract pays the contractor the actual cost of the work plus a fee, with no ceiling on the total. A GMP is a cost-plus contract with a ceiling added. Both are open book and both reimburse real cost, but under plain cost-plus the owner pays every dollar of an overrun, while under a GMP the contractor pays whatever lands above the cap. The AIA's own form titles draw the same line: A103-2017 pays "the Cost of the Work Plus a Fee without a Guaranteed Maximum Price", and A102-2017 pays it "with a Guaranteed Maximum Price".
| Cost-plus | GMP | |
|---|---|---|
| Ceiling on total cost | None | Yes, the GMP |
| Overrun | Owner pays | Owner pays up to the cap, contractor pays above it |
| Savings | All to the owner | Shared under the savings clause, or all to the owner |
| Contractor's fee | Fixed, a percentage of cost, or a percentage with a cap | Usually fixed or a percentage, set in the contract |
| Contingency | Not needed inside the price | The contractor's contingency sits inside the cap |
| When it can start | Earliest, even before design is far along | Once the design is far enough along to price a cap |
Owners pick cost-plus when speed matters more than price certainty and the scope can't be known at the start. They pick a GMP when they want that same open-book transparency with a ceiling to finance against. The cost-plus fee type matters most. A percentage of cost grows as costs grow, so owners who use cost-plus usually ask for a fixed or capped fee.
What Are the Four Main Contract Pricing Models?
There are four pricing structures you will quote on most US commercial work.
Lump sum, also called a stipulated sum contract, is a single fixed price for a defined scope. You take off the drawings, price the work, add overhead and profit, and commit to a number. If the job costs less, you keep the difference. If it costs more, you eat it.
GMP sets a ceiling the owner will not exceed for a defined scope, and you bill actual cost plus a fee up to it. See GMP for the mechanics.
Cost-plus reimburses your actual cost of the work plus a fee. The fee can be a fixed dollar amount, a percentage of cost, or a percentage with a not-to-exceed cap. Pure cost-plus with a percentage fee and no cap is the most owner-exposed structure of the four.
Unit price pays a fixed rate per unit of work installed, for example an illustrative $14 per cubic yard of structural fill or $9 per linear foot of curb. The owner pays for the quantities actually placed, measured in the field. It fits work where the design is set but the quantity is genuinely unknown until you dig.
Negotiated commercial work is often bought as a GMP contract, and a 2024 Morris, Manning & Martin article calls the GMP model "today's most common pricing structure" in construction agreements. Hard-bid public work is usually lump sum. Cost-plus shows up on fast-track and heavily owner-directed jobs. Unit price is common in sitework, earthwork, and utilities, and it routinely lives as a line-item structure inside a larger lump sum or GMP contract.
Who Carries the Risk Under Each Model?
Risk allocation is the whole conversation. Here is who holds what.
Under lump sum, the contractor carries cost risk. Once the price is set, every dollar of overrun is yours, and every dollar of underrun is yours. The owner carries scope risk: if the drawings are incomplete and you have to build something the documents did not show, that is a change order and the price moves. This is why lump sum punishes thin documents. You will load contingency and markup to cover what you cannot see, and the owner pays for that uncertainty whether or not it materializes.
Under cost-plus, the owner carries cost risk. You are reimbursed for what the work actually costs, so an overrun lands on the owner's side of the ledger. Your exposure is limited to running the job efficiently enough to protect your reputation and your fee. With a percentage fee and no cap, your fee actually grows as costs grow, which is the incentive misalignment owners worry about.
Under GMP, risk is split at the cap. Below the guaranteed maximum, the owner carries cost risk the same as cost-plus. Above the cap, you carry it the same as lump sum. The savings clause then gives you a reason to push costs down, because you share in the underrun rather than just handing it all back.
Under unit price, the contractor carries the risk of the rate being right and the owner carries the risk of the quantity. You guarantee your unit cost is correct. The owner accepts that final quantities, and therefore the final total, are not known at signing.
For the general contractor, the risk shows up in different places. Under lump sum it is scope the takeoff missed. Under cost-plus it is a dispute over what counts as reimbursable cost. Under a GMP it is a cap signed too early, an allowance priced too low, or contingency spent before the hard trades are bought. The GMP glossary entry lists the GMP risks in full.
What Is the Open-Book vs Closed-Book Distinction?
Open-book means the owner can see your actual costs: invoices, payroll, subcontractor billings, equipment rates, the works. Closed-book means they see a price and nothing behind it.
Lump sum is closed-book by nature. The owner agreed to a number. How you spend against it is your business, and your margin is yours to protect. They do not get to audit your buyout.
Cost-plus and GMP are open-book by nature, because the owner is reimbursing real cost and has to be able to verify it. That visibility is the trade. The owner sees your numbers, and in exchange they take on more of the cost risk.
Unit price is partly open: the rates are agreed and visible, but the rate buildup behind each unit is usually yours.
What Does Each Contract Have to Spell Out?
Each contract type needs different things written down, and most disputes start where they weren't.
- Lump sum needs a tight scope: inclusions, exclusions, allowances and the drawings the price is based on. With no audit, the scope is the whole contract.
- Cost-plus needs a definition of cost of the work, the fee and how it is calculated, the allowable markup on changes, and the owner's audit rights.
- GMP needs everything cost-plus needs, plus the cap, the assumptions behind it, how contingency gets drawn and who owns what is left, and the savings split.
What goes into a GMP and its amendment in detail is on the GMP glossary entry.
When Should an Owner Choose GMP, Lump Sum or Cost-Plus?
Match the model to the maturity of the documents and the owner's appetite for risk.
Use lump sum when the scope is fully designed and you can take off complete drawings with confidence. Hard-bid public work, tenant improvements off finished construction documents, and well-defined building shells fit here. The owner gets price certainty and a clean number to finance against. They pay for that certainty through the contingency you build into the price.
Use GMP when the owner wants a ceiling but the design is not fully complete, which describes most negotiated commercial work. GMP lets you start while drawings finish, gives the owner a cap to underwrite, and the open-book structure plus the savings split keeps incentives roughly aligned. It is the workhorse of negotiated delivery for a reason.
A 2010 study by Bogus, Shane and Molenaar, published in Public Works Management and Policy, found in a survey of public owners that municipal water and wastewater projects paid cost plus a fee with a GMP were more likely to finish with no cost or schedule growth than lump-sum projects.
Use cost-plus when speed matters more than price certainty and the scope is genuinely unknowable at the start. Emergency restoration, early site mobilization ahead of design, and heavily owner-directed work fit. Owners should pair it with a fixed or capped fee so your compensation does not balloon with cost.
Use unit price when the design is set but the quantity is not, the classic case being earthwork, undercut, rock removal, and utilities. Nobody knows how much unsuitable soil is down there until the excavator hits it, so you price the rate and measure the field.
Choose the contract by reading the documents in front of you. Complete drawings and a price-certain owner point to lump sum. Incomplete drawings and an owner who wants a ceiling point to GMP with a clean savings clause and a tight definition of cost of the work. Genuine unknowns in quantity point to unit price, and genuine unknowns in scope point to a capped-fee cost-plus. Whichever model you land on, the discipline is the same: define the scope as far as the documents allow, put the contingency where the risk actually sits, write the open-book terms so nobody argues about them later, and make sure the price you sign reflects the work you can see. The structure decides who carries the risk. Your estimate decides whether anyone gets hurt by it.
The Same $5M Job Under GMP, Lump Sum and Cost-Plus
The same work costs the owner a different amount under each contract, even when the building is identical. Take one job with a fixed fee of $300,000. The lump sum price and the GMP are both $5,000,000, and the GMP has an 80/20 savings split in the owner's favor. These figures are illustrative.
Under budget: the cost of the work comes in at $4,400,000.
| Owner pays | Contractor keeps over cost of the work | |
|---|---|---|
| Lump sum | $5,000,000 | $600,000 |
| Cost-plus | $4,700,000 ($4,400,000 plus the $300,000 fee) | $300,000, the fee |
| GMP | $4,760,000 | $360,000, the fee plus a $60,000 savings share |
Under the GMP, cost plus fee is $4,700,000, which is $300,000 under the cap. The savings clause gives $240,000 to the owner and $60,000 to the contractor.
Over budget: the cost of the work comes in at $4,900,000.
| Owner pays | Contractor keeps over cost of the work | |
|---|---|---|
| Lump sum | $5,000,000 | $100,000 |
| Cost-plus | $5,200,000 ($4,900,000 plus the $300,000 fee) | $300,000, the fee |
| GMP | $5,000,000 | $100,000, because the $200,000 overrun comes out of the fee |
Below the cap, a GMP behaves like cost-plus. Above it, it behaves like lump sum. With a percentage fee instead, say an illustrative 7 percent of cost, the cost-plus fee would rise from $308,000 to $343,000 as cost went up, which is why owners prefer a fixed fee. In practice a lump sum bid often carries more contingency than a GMP for the same scope, because the contractor keeps all overrun risk, so the two prices rarely match. The savings split itself is worked through on the GMP glossary entry.
Whichever contract you sign, the number rests on the takeoff. Ruh AI's Estimating Agent prices from your own rate book and history, and a person on your team approves every scope line before Ruh measures it.
Try Ruh on a real bid.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a GMP and a lump sum contract?+
A lump sum is a closed-book fixed price: the contractor keeps every dollar of savings and pays every dollar of overrun, and the owner sees no actual costs. A GMP is open book and pays actual cost plus a fee up to a cap. The owner can audit costs, and an underrun flows back to the owner in whole or in part. Lump sum bidding usually needs complete documents, while a GMP is commonly set earlier in design, with contingency and written qualifications covering the gaps.
Who carries the cost overrun risk in a cost-plus contract?+
The owner does. Cost-plus reimburses the contractor's actual cost plus a fee, so an overrun lands on the owner's side. To limit that exposure, owners should use a fixed or capped fee rather than a straight percentage of cost, which otherwise grows the contractor's fee as costs rise.
What does open-book mean in a construction contract?+
Open-book means the owner can see and audit the contractor's actual costs, including invoices, payroll, and subcontractor billings. GMP and cost-plus are open-book because the owner reimburses real cost and must verify it. Lump sum is closed-book: the owner agreed to a fixed number and does not see the cost behind it.
When should I use a unit price contract?+
Use unit price when the design is set but the quantity is unknown until the work is done, such as earthwork, undercut, rock removal, and utilities. The owner pays an agreed rate per unit installed and accepts that the final total depends on field quantities. It often appears as line items inside a larger lump sum or GMP contract.
Who keeps the savings under GMP, lump sum and cost-plus?+
Under lump sum the contractor keeps all of it. Under cost-plus the owner keeps all of it, because it only pays actual cost plus the fee. Under a GMP the underrun is split by the savings clause, or returned in full to the owner if the contract says so. The split math is on the GMP glossary entry.
Is a GMP a cost-plus contract?+
Yes. A GMP is cost-plus with a ceiling. The AIA's A102-2017 is titled for payment of "the Cost of the Work Plus a Fee with a Guaranteed Maximum Price", and A103-2017 is the same arrangement without one.
Which is riskier for the contractor, GMP or lump sum?+
Both put cost above the agreed price or cap on the contractor, so the difference is in the upside. Lump sum lets the contractor keep all the savings, and GMP usually shares them. A GMP adds audit risk, because costs the contract does not define as reimbursable can be disallowed. Lump sum adds scope risk, because there is no reimbursement for anything the takeoff missed.
Is cost-plus or GMP better for the owner?+
A GMP, when the design is far enough along to price a cap, because it adds a ceiling to the same open-book terms. Cost-plus suits work that has to start before anyone can price it, such as emergency repairs, and owners usually pair it with a fixed or capped fee.
Still pricing in a spreadsheet? Your price book, automated end to end. Your estimator signs off.
See it runTerms Used in This Guide
Figures on this page are illustrative. Construction estimates depend on project-specific conditions, source documents, market pricing, and professional judgment. Ruh's AI assists the estimator and does not replace professional review: your team reviews, validates, and approves every estimate, bid, and pricing decision.


